I am forced to admit almost two years later asking the question, isn’t the Secret just another self help book? Every generation has one Norman Vincent Peals, The Power of Positive Thinking in the sixties I want to say, then Tony Roberts, Unleash the Giant Within You, in the eighties, and now comes The Secret another self help book. Having an advanced degree in psychology has made me think about many aspects of the Law of Attraction. Any book with sound principles in the self help category is not all bad, especially those who are hungry for it and committed to helping themselves in a positive fashion that will enrich their lives.
One troubling thought in the Secret is that working hard to achieve goals is not necessary. I would think most would agree , most people work hard to get what we want in life, regardless of what it is. It was not given to us nor did we get it because we visualized it over and over. This type of thinking could lead someone to really believe that one does not have to work in this life to attain their goal, and then time goes by, and more time and then the realization comes to mind, yes you do have to work for what you want, and they find themselves out there hustling for a job, any job. My boss is an Army Ranger, now that is an elite group of men similar to the Navy Seal, but more demanding in several areas than the Navy Seal, and he spent four and one half years in Afghanistan and Iran, as a sniper. The mental and physical requirements for both of these Special Forces will separate the men from the boys, literally. Easy, of course not, it’s called hard work. Before he was deployed he found his niche in sales, confident and excellent at his job. He is only 34 and has brought 2 national companies to hit all time sales records and substantial growth. I commented that he was born confident and had a knack for sales, He said , not so, I worked at it daily over and over and still do. He is one of the most level headed feet planted firmly on the ground individuals I have ever met. Hard work brought him what he has already attained at such a young age. To suggest he visualized his success is asinine, and totally absurd.
The Secret suggests visualization too frequently, and an example was the young man who visualized a feather.Days later as he is entering a building in NYC, he spots a feather at the entrance of the building and there is the feather he had visualized. Whatever type of feather he visualized, it must have been in the pigeon family, no exotic birds in NYC to the best of my knowledge. Visualization comes in handy when you are picturing in your mind how you want a project to turn out, whatever it might be. But you will have to do more than visualize to bring it to fruition.
You also can’t bury feelings of negativity, you have to deal with them with whatever means you have available. 85% of families in the US are dysfunctional in some capacity. You can’t blame whatever went on for your inability to move forward in life, in this case you have to deal with it, burying the feeling does not work, for one day it will rear its ugly head in ways you never imagined. This does not mean some gut wrenching, turning yourself inside and out for months or years at a time. It means tackling it head on, and for once put it away. Let’s face it, you have the choice to either blame the past or deal with it. So the suggestion that having negative feelings will bring more, I find rather scary, of course an individual who has had some severe trauma in their life is going to think about it upon occasion, This does not mean that if you do, something bad will happen. This is a frightening concept.
There are those who prefer the negative and do not see much positive in life, well, these people will never be happy and do not even recognize how negative they really are, so everything that happens to them will be interpreted as bad.
Another concept I have a problem with is the explanation that some people do not get what they want in this life because they don’t feel deeply enough. I simply find this outlandish. Again, asking for whatever you want in life is a one time deal. You ask , and that is it, an example why you do not need to ask again is simple. If you order a car, you order it once, if you order airline tickets, you only have to order once., so when do I do all this feeling . And all the talk about the genie, I am forever picturing the genie popping out of the bottle, your wish is my command and he is so dumb he supposedly doesn’t know a good wish from a bad one. I do not have time to examine every thought that goes through my mind, and if there happens to be a negative one like, damn I am going to be late, well the genie says your wish is my command and you will be late.
I got into reading this and understanding the way the Secret works, but the more I read and listened the more I began to see a lot of things that are counter productive, and admit I feel rather stupid at the moment that after I read it I didn’t chalk it up to what it is, another self help book for this generation. I see some good, positive thoughts, kindness, don’t hate, show generosity and love your enemies, love period. These are great attributes we should all have, but they are not new concepts .
Well , now that I have started this, I am going to continue with what I find a tad dangerous in the teachings of the secret. Maybe I was at a point in life where I needed something to believe in. And this is the best I could come up with, although my daughter and best friend are very high on the Secret. It’s their fault. LOL